Students and faculty are split over standardized testing in University of California admissions, with a protest reported in San Francisco and professors urging a return to SAT/ACT requirements.
Protest reported at UC San Francisco
A Tuesday protest at the University of California at San Francisco brought out 100 students to oppose bringing back the SAT or ACT, the New York Post reported.

During public comment at a UC Board of Regents meeting, Candice Phan — identified as UCSA president and a UC Davis undergraduate — said, “So rather than blaming students, the UC needs to look itself in the mirror, assess the landscape and timeline which we are in, and decide how we are to move forward in a way that truly centers student experience, equity, and access,” according to the Post.
Faculty cite readiness concerns
Joel Hass, professor and chair of the UC Davis Department of Mathematics, said, “Standardized testing is the only objective method available in the admissions process that compares student preparedness across different schools. It provides essential information to the admissions process,” as quoted in the article. Hass backed a push from math and science faculty to require standardized tests for applicants to STEM majors and added, “I believe we should reinstate standardized tests for all applicants,” according to the report.
Hass also said, “Being admitted without necessary preparation can derail a student’s educational trajectory, causing unnecessary failure and discouragement,” and attributed current problems to “a combination of poor practices in K–12 education and a failure of the processes of the UC admission system,” as quoted in the article.
What a cited letter claims
A letter referenced in the article said that at UC San Diego, 70 percent of students tested below middle school level in math, and that at UC Berkeley, the share of freshmen with “severe preparation deficits” was between 20 percent and 30 percent for three consecutive years. The letter also cited “severe grade inflation” and “AI-assisted application essays.”
Earlier stance against testing
The article notes that colleges, including the University of California, dropped SAT/ACT requirements in recent years. At the time, UC Regent Jonathan “Jay” Sures said, “I believe the test is a racist test. There’s no two ways about it,” according to the Daily Signal. The Daily Signal also characterized the return of testing at some colleges as a response to worries that students “were taking classes but not bothering to learn anything.”
The report did not indicate any final decision by the UC Regents on admissions testing.

